Re: Critique My Frame!

Oh, that is very nice; it's much clearer what we're looking at, and it does feel like it's underwater, as opposed to just really dark.

Re: Critique My Frame!

Masked, but not edited otherwise. This is supposed to be outer space, how does it look? Is the ship too hard to see?

https://c4.staticflickr.com/8/7530/27532474251_0bd4c938c0_z.jpg

Re: Critique My Frame!

That looks really cool, but I do think you need more light on the ship (I didn't realize there was one until I read your question about it mini/tongue ).

Re: Critique My Frame!

It is a bit hard to see, but if it moves in front of the stars, it's fine.
The stars are too big in my opinion. It's more supposed to be small bright white points than blurry blue circles. There is some kind of subaquatic feel to this frame.

Re: Critique My Frame!

The big light in the center is grabbing all the attention. I couldn't even see the ship until I really squinted. Maybe once it passed over the light it would have a good rimlight which would show the ship, but currently, it's really hard to see.

YouTubeWebsite
https://bricksafe.com/files/rioforce/internet-images/RioforceBiMSig.png
"Whatever you do, do all to the glory of God." - 1 Corinthians 10:31b

Re: Critique My Frame!

Thanks for the feedback, guys. How's this? If it's too blue, I may just need to adjust the shutter speed, if not I can fix in in post production.

https://c5.staticflickr.com/8/7113/27510384492_c2e40a249a_c.jpg

Re: Critique My Frame!

That's a lot better. You can see the ship clearly now.

Re: Critique My Frame!

Seems like a very soft like to show the spaceship better.

Here's a frame of my current project, Heads:

http://i.imgur.com/Eb9AWoJ.png

The character in focus is the one speaking in this particular shot. Is the foreground character too obnoxious?

Re: Critique My Frame!

I don't think it's too obnoxious. The one in focus definitely grabs more attention.

Re: Critique My Frame!

Nice frame jasper, the set looks very nice judging from this. I do not think the foreground character is obnoxious. I actually like the amount of blur you have and how you chose to light him/her, considering the distance between the two and how close the foreground character is to the camera.

The only critique I can really think of is the composition. I think the left side of the frame feels a tad empty if you compare it to the right side. The right side has darker walls towards the edge of the frame, obviously caused by some shadow of sorts, and it is filled with desks in the background and the character in the foreground. The left side only has the in-focus character and that brown "box" in the foreground. Perhaps moving the middle-ground character a bit to the left could help.

I realise I may be a bit out of my league with my critique, considering my experience, but I felt I should tell you what I felt I could to help you. Other than that slight nitpick, I really like this frame. The middle-ground character is in crisp focus. The set details are wonderful, the colours are a tad too red but perhaps that's your style choice and the angle of the composition is really lovely. I hope you will post more preview frames for us to see. mini/smile

Re: Critique My Frame!

not obnoxious.

https://vimeo.com/channels/holdingourown      http://holding-our-own.tumblr.com

"None practice tolerance less frequently than those who most loudly preach it."

Re: Critique My Frame!

LMDigitalMovies wrote:

Nice frame jasper, the set looks very nice judging from this. I do not think the foreground character is obnoxious. I actually like the amount of blur you have and how you chose to light him/her, considering the distance between the two and how close the foreground character is to the camera.

The only critique I can really think of is the composition. I think the left side of the frame feels a tad empty if you compare it to the right side. The right side has darker walls towards the edge of the frame, obviously caused by some shadow of sorts, and it is filled with desks in the background and the character in the foreground. The left side only has the in-focus character and that brown "box" in the foreground. Perhaps moving the middle-ground character a bit to the left could help.

I realise I may be a bit out of my league with my critique, considering my experience, but I felt I should tell you what I felt I could to help you. Other than that slight nitpick, I really like this frame. The middle-ground character is in crisp focus. The set details are wonderful, the colours are a tad too red but perhaps that's your style choice and the angle of the composition is really lovely. I hope you will post more preview frames for us to see. mini/smile

Thanks for your feedback. I would move the character to the left a bit to keep the balance, but this frame is already in the middle of a scene. Previously the character had just got up from the couch, and I just animated that. So the character is stuck in that position.

Re: Critique My Frame!

Here's a sneak peak frame from my Batman vs Superman short mini/smile
https://s32.postimg.org/th1hauo5h/SHOT_1_00000.png

Re: Critique My Frame!

I like that frame Larry Simmons!

Here's a frame from my current project.  I've been working on the film for about a month now.
http://bricksafe.com/files/Wammy/DSC_0016.jpg

https://bricksafe.com/files/Wammy/Our%20Friend%20Pablo.jpg  Watch it on YouTube!

"Surely goodness and mercy shall follow me all the days of my life: and I will dwell in the house of the LORD for ever."
~ Psalm 23:6 ~

Re: Critique My Frame!

Really cool lighting there.

Re: Critique My Frame!

Frame from my short recreating the Apollo 11 landing
http://imgur.com/YtleYAw.jpg

Re: Critique My Frame!

more and more the frames to be critiqued are low-light images.

https://vimeo.com/channels/holdingourown      http://holding-our-own.tumblr.com

"None practice tolerance less frequently than those who most loudly preach it."

Re: Critique My Frame!

Hey Swingler,

The frame is way too dark for the moon imo. If you look at photos of the moon landing (and I'd say this goes for most outer space scenes in general), the lighting is brighter and the contrast between light and shadows is much harsher. Also, I think it would help if the lighting was a bit cooler (ie more blue). Try messing with the white balance.

Rioforce's Sola Luna is a good example of lunar lighting done well in a brickfilm. You may wanna check it out mini/wink

Last edited by Brickcrazy (July 14, 2016 (02:14pm))

YouTube  |  Flickr  |  Twitter

Re: Critique My Frame!

Here is a frame for The Adventures of Jane which I think might be my favorite frame from the film mini/smile

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/CnYqfOKUAAM8z5f.jpg:large

Re: Critique My Frame!

That is quite beautiful.

"I wear black even when I'm not animating. I'm like a walking funeral parlor."
-PushOverProductions