Is anyone besides and The Janitor me a PK fan?  I love those wacky dudes.

Juggernaut Pictures wrote:

I give TCOTY the story, it has that over unrenewable. But, the animation is average, the the quality of the voice actors mics are horrible, and the camera... ew. So from a story yes TCOTY is better, but the technical aspects of Unrenewable, the compositing, the camera quality, the effects, masking, CGI, animation, facial animation, grading, lighting, and cinematography is much better in Unrenewable, now I realize that Unrenewable was made in a more modern time than TCOTY, but TCOTY still does not compare to the technical aspects of Unrenewable. And I feel that it is quite unfair to exclude all of the other great brickfilms (Picturesque, The River, and even a modern one like The Force Unleashed) and just call one the "best brickfilm" and slap every other animator in the face. It is fine to have an opinion, but to make a holiday, and state it as a fact that it is the best, is arrogant, rude, obnoxious, bias, and disrespectful to every other brickfilmer. Sorry to ruin the holiday cheer but this is simply how we feel.

Hey, calm down. I never said it sucks, or that I don't like the voice acting, or the effects, or animation (well, also, in unrenewable, the animation isn't the strongest part). You know, none of these things are what make a brickfilm great. And plus, Tcoty isn't my favourite brickfilm, 12 bucks is, and I honestly don't think it really is the best brickfilm ever. Neither Unrenewable is. Probably neither 12 bucks it. It's really difficult to make everybody agree on which one the best brickfilm is, you know why. Sorry for any disrespectful acting I had, obnoxious, rude, arrogant or whatever. It wasn't my intention. Also my post was more of a joke than a serious post.

P.S.: Masking? In tcoty there isn't any shot where masking is used (correct me if I'm wrong). And I have to disagree with you that voice acting and animation is better in Unrenewable than in tcoty.

P.P.S.: Sorry if in this last post I was a bit arrogant or rude again, I was a bit surprised anyone would take my previous post seriously, and seeing you complaining and insulting (by that I mean calling me rude, abnoxious etc etc...I don't know the right term) me about that, made me go mad.

P.P.P.S.: Vik, the list is coming in my next post, probably . If there is going to be a next post.

Edit: sorry, last thing. I think The River can be considered a classic, not sure about the other two (especially picturesque). There are a lot of "modern great films".

MPfist0 wrote:

Juggernaut Pictures wrote:

I give TCOTY the story, it has that over unrenewable. But, the animation is average, the the quality of the voice actors mics are horrible, and the camera... ew. So from a story yes TCOTY is better, but the technical aspects of Unrenewable, the compositing, the camera quality, the effects, masking, CGI, animation, facial animation, grading, lighting, and cinematography is much better in Unrenewable, now I realize that Unrenewable was made in a more modern time than TCOTY, but TCOTY still does not compare to the technical aspects of Unrenewable. And I feel that it is quite unfair to exclude all of the other great brickfilms (Picturesque, The River, and even a modern one like The Force Unleashed) and just call one the "best brickfilm" and slap every other animator in the face. It is fine to have an opinion, but to make a holiday, and state it as a fact that it is the best, is arrogant, rude, obnoxious, bias, and disrespectful to every other brickfilmer. Sorry to ruin the holiday cheer but this is simply how we feel.

Hey, calm down. I never said it sucks, or that I don't like the voice acting, or the effects, or animation (well, also, in unrenewable, the animation isn't the strongest part). You know, none of these things are what make a brickfilm great. And plus, Tcoty isn't my favourite brickfilm, 12 bucks is, and I honestly don't think it really is the best brickfilm ever. Neither Unrenewable is. Probably neither 12 bucks it. It's really difficult to make everybody agree on which one the best brickfilm is, you know why. Sorry for any disrespectful acting I had, obnoxious, rude, arrogant or whatever. It wasn't my intention. Also my post was more of a joke than a serious post.

P.S.: Masking? In tcoty there isn't any shot where masking is used (correct me if I'm wrong). And I have to disagree with you that voice acting and animation is better in Unrenewable than in tcoty.

P.P.S.: Sorry if in this last post I was a bit arrogant or rude again, I was a bit surprised anyone would take my previous post seriously, and seeing you complaining and insulting (by that I mean calling me rude, abnoxious etc etc...I don't know the right term) me about that, made me go mad.

P.P.P.S.: Vik, the list is coming in my next post, probably . If there is going to be a next post.

Edit: sorry, last thing. I think The River can be considered a classic, not sure about the other two (especially picturesque). There are a lot of "modern great films".

We weren't actually just talking to you, it's not wrong to have an opinion. And you weren't disrespectful in any way. Sadly it looks like we (yes we are 3 people) did what we flamed everyone for, we pretty much stated that Unrenewable is the best when it is actually an opinion.