I agree with Pritchard on all points, but do have a few I could add.
The story didn't seem at all like a stand alone story, but a scene out of a movie.
One thing I think might have helped a lot here would have been changing the aspect ratio. If you pause it at almost any frame, it's got a pretty cinematic feel to it, between the lighting, color correction, and framing. All that looks really good together, the next thing would be a much wider aspect ratio. 16:9 could have really made this look 'real', I think. Take a look at these poorly made examples:




Also, while doing that, I realized that he seemed to be just slightly out of focus during a lot of shots. Might want to try and fix that.