Topic: Smallish Rant About Mod Elements

I was going to post this in another topic, but it happens so often, I just decided to go and make a thread about it.

Firstly, does anyone understand why the mod element was created in the first place? Simple: it was created so that the judges of the Twenty-Four Hour Animation Competition (THAC) would know if a shot was filmed within the 24 hours or not. That's why your film gets disqualified if you forget to put it in your shot, because despite what you may say, there is no way for the judges to know that you filmed that shot within the 24 hours.

Now why the rant? Because so many members who decide to make a contest on here make the mod element a part of the contest, whether the contest has a time limit or not. Why is this bad? One, the mod element is an annoying but necessary part of THAC. Having it in every other contest is just overkill. Now, you may think of other contests where a certain phrase or object must be inserted in the film. These are totally different, because that element usually affects some part of the story, so a certain amount of creativity is involved in putting that phrase/object in. The mod element, on the other hand, is just there, no creativity required. Not fun at all.

Two, if your contest does not have a time limit, there is absolutely no point in having it there, since it's only purpose is to ensure something was made inside the time limit. Now, there are some contests where the material you enter into that contest MUST have been made for that contest, so they require the mod element for that — but I think those contests are totally lame, and I'll leave it at that.

Please, if you're going to make a contest, put some creativity into it. Skip the mod element, and instead put in something like a maximum animation limit of 15 seconds, or incorporating non-LEGO elements (I've always wanted to use broccoli for trees). These may seem harder to do, but that's the point! They should encourage you to think creatively, which makes the contest more fun/challenging, and should inspire better films.

"[It] was the theme song for the movie 2010 first contact." ~ A YouTuber on Also Sprach Zarathustra
CGI LEGO! Updated occasionally...

Re: Smallish Rant About Mod Elements

I agree, we seem to have had a shortage of creative contests in recent monthes.

Don't be fooled, my avatar is a facade of conformity.

Re: Smallish Rant About Mod Elements

I completely agree, I was just reading this thread and I thought to my self why is there a need for a "Mod Element".

http://i.imgur.com/jaA3e.png
"No, please, I love you..." jstudios on Skype... <He was talking to me<              News!

Re: Smallish Rant About Mod Elements

I remember before I came to BiM, and I watched THAC entries, and I saw a random letter I was like "What is going on?" mini/confused

Re: Smallish Rant About Mod Elements

Matthew wrote:

I completely agree, I was just reading this thread and I thought to my self why is there a need for a "Mod Element".

Well, the Mod Element is there to make sure people actually make a brickfilm for the challenge, and don't submit a pre-made brickfilm. Otherwise it would be unfair, because while you would be working hard on creating a good film especially for the theme, 10 other people could submit pre-made entries, therefore disqualifying your film (and we would have no way to prove that their entries were made before yours).

http://www.majhost.com/gallery/StudioL30/Random-Pictures/youtube.jpghttp://www.majhost.com/gallery/StudioL30/Random-Pictures/sitelogo.jpg

Re: Smallish Rant About Mod Elements

I disagree that the Ten Entry Challenge does not need a mod element, as its main purpose is for you to be one of the first ten people to complete a film after the theme is announced. It doesn't have a definite time limit, but it is in this way a timed contest. I think the creator understood the purpose of a mod element.

Now, there are some contests where the material you enter into that contest MUST have been made for that contest, so they require the mod element for that — but I think those contests are totally lame, and I'll leave it at that.

I don't see how having a contest in which entries must be made specifically for the contest is in any way more "lame" than having a contest in which people can submit any random film they've been working on that happens to fit the theme. If anything, requiring the film to have been made for the contest makes more sense; in any other situation someone working on a film long before has both an unfair advantage (not due to any sort of intentional cheating, but still an advantage), and was ultimately planning to have made the film anyway, so the community doesn't benefit from the contest either. I won't say I think we should require mod elements in every contest, or tell people not to enter films they've already put significant time into, but I will say that I don't follow your logic at all.

This community obviously puts a lot of stock into creativity. I don't think another badgering about how people should be more creative will lead to a rise in more creative people.

Re: Smallish Rant About Mod Elements

Reading all of the above has made me change my mind.

http://i.imgur.com/jaA3e.png
"No, please, I love you..." jstudios on Skype... <He was talking to me<              News!