Hmm that was sort of sick. I like some dark humor but I can't say that this appealed to me, it reminds me of something a cartoonist (Scott Adams I think) who said that in general, animals hurting people can be funny, and animals hurting animals can be funny, but people hurting animals isn't.
Any way the technical work was nice as always, I liked the springy jumping animation on the title character.
Regarding the whole eligibility thing I would probably favor lenience, but to be fair Munzapoppa is just enforcing the rules. With BRAWL, more so than most contests, the main prize is having a new short film you're proud of at the end of the week.