Topic: Webcam VS. DSLR

So after recently joining BiM, I have found that many (almost a mojority) of brickfilmers use webcams. Are they better for brickfilming than a DSLR? I certainly don't need all 18 megapixels of the photos that the DSLR I use is giving me. Don't get me wrong, I really really like the DSLR, though it is a hassle to position it properly and it's weight (and lack of a tripod) really limit the angles that I can use. It is amazing for photography, but I'm not into photography as much as animation.

So, all of this boils down to one question. Would it be worth looking into getting a webcam for brickfilming? After all, the camera is my sister's mini/tongue .

http://i1302.photobucket.com/albums/ag121/CavemanIncorporated/BiM_Sig_Monkey_zpse6d51622.jpg

Re: Webcam VS. DSLR

Webcams are more convenient and sometimes the quality is pretty good. You can't zoom with most webcams though, which is a downside if you don't want the whole film to look like it was shot on one, wideish lens.

You never need more than like 8 megapixels anyway, because you're probably planning to make your videos at a resolution no higher than 1080p. With a DSLR you will need a lens that can focus very close for the LEGO scale, or diopter filters to focus closer on a normal lens, but diopters make the depth of field more shallow.

Personally, I prefer shooting with a compact, fixed-lens digital camera. I've used a Canon A620 for most of my films; a Canon A-series powershot camera might suit your needs if you can find one that works with your stop motion software of choice. The quality's better than a webcam, but the camera isn't as bulky and they mostly include macro-focusing features.

http://i.imgur.com/wcmcdmf.png

Re: Webcam VS. DSLR

Pretty much all my films are done on the little digital camera like Smeagol said, but I am going to start using webcam because I have a lot of trouble with keeping the camera still. The way I have my rig set up doesn't allow me any good angles so that is why I am considering switching. Back when I made my first brickfilm, I used a DSLR for a brickfilm once, and I had a lot of trouble with making it stay focused on the legos. (I was so embarrassed that I posted it on a different account- Blame the bad animation on me, not the camera). Despite all this, the DSLR has the amazing quality that is not easily reproducible. So if you are able to do it well, like ANP, then it is worth it, but otherwise I would suggest the digital camera. mini/smile

Re: Webcam VS. DSLR

DSLR's have other advantages besides very high image quality. One of the more subtle ones is better dynamic color range. You can also adjust the lighting of your shot much more exactly, so on and so forth, there are a lot of benefits. I must say though, I've never used anything other than a DSLR, so I don't know much about other cameras. Also, since you're using your sisters camera I must warn you, SLR's have a finite life, the shutter mechanism will eventually die out, so by using her camera for animation (which involves taking tons of pictures, if you hadn't noticed), you are speeding up her camera's journey to inevitable death; something to keep in mind. mini/smile

Re: Webcam VS. DSLR

Sméagol wrote:

You never need more than like 8 megapixels anyway, because you're probably planning to make your videos at a resolution no higher than 1080p.

Just to make it clear. You on't need more than 3 megapixels because Full HD (1080p) is lessthan 3 megapixels.

http://www.usa.canon.com/assets/app/images/callouts/cameras/callout_hdvideo_091511.jpg    http://www.usa.canon.com/assets/app/images/callouts/cameras/cdlc_148_rt.jpg

Re: Webcam VS. DSLR

Sméagol wrote:
You never need more than like 8 megapixels anyway, because you're probably planning to make your videos at a resolution no higher than 1080p.

Just to make it clear. You on't need more than 3 megapixels because Full HD (1080p) is lessthan 3 megapixels.

Yes, though cameras with >3 Megapixels tend to have very poor optics and coloring. I was unaware that webcams were unable to zoom, so I may look into getting a small camera with decent quality that is compatible with my frame-capture software mini/smile

Anything else that I should be aware of?

http://i1302.photobucket.com/albums/ag121/CavemanIncorporated/BiM_Sig_Monkey_zpse6d51622.jpg

Re: Webcam VS. DSLR

I highly recommend the Canon Powershot series of compact cameras (like Smeagol has). In most cases their image quality is better than any webcam. And they have certain key features, such as zoom capability, that would benefit your films.

http://www.usa.canon.com/assets/app/images/callouts/cameras/callout_hdvideo_091511.jpg    http://www.usa.canon.com/assets/app/images/callouts/cameras/cdlc_148_rt.jpg

Re: Webcam VS. DSLR

do you know what capture software supports canon powershots with windows 7? because when I was looking at stop motion pro, it said that it only supported canon powershots on windows xp and free ware does not seem to support it or I can't find the answers. The only other software  I could think of is dragonframe but that is way out of my budget mini/confused

Re: Webcam VS. DSLR

Do cannon power shots have full manual operation?

http://i1302.photobucket.com/albums/ag121/CavemanIncorporated/BiM_Sig_Monkey_zpse6d51622.jpg

Re: Webcam VS. DSLR

some of them do and some of them don't you would have to check the specifications, however apparently some lose their manual focus when on remote capture

Re: Webcam VS. DSLR

I personally use a DSLR, but then again I bought it for live-action projects and 'coz photography is another hobby of mine.

http://www.brickshelf.com/gallery/ZoefDeHaas/stuff/sig1.png
"Nothing goes down 'less I'm involved. No nuggets. No onion rings. No nothin'. A cheeseburger gets sold in the park, I want in! You got fat while we starved on the streets...now it's my turn!" -Harley Morenstein

Re: Webcam VS. DSLR

VanderFlame Studios wrote:
Sméagol wrote:

You never need more than like 8 megapixels anyway, because you're probably planning to make your videos at a resolution no higher than 1080p.

Just to make it clear. You on't need more than 3 megapixels because Full HD (1080p) is lessthan 3 megapixels.

Theoretically true, but in practice it's usually better to have something that captures more and resolves down to 1080p because a 3 megapixel camera will generally produce a softer image at 1080p than an 8 megapixel camera. The exception would be if it's a camera built specifically for resolving to video resolutions, like the Blackmagic Cinema Camera.

The other thing I like is being able to crop and zoom a little bit digitally in post, which a high resolution enables you to do.

http://i.imgur.com/wcmcdmf.png

Re: Webcam VS. DSLR

DSLR's have other advantages besides very high image quality. One of the more subtle ones is better dynamic color range. You can also adjust the lighting of your shot much more exactly, so on and so forth, there are a lot of benefits. I must say though, I've never used anything other than a DSLR, so I don't know much about other cameras. Also, since you're using your sisters camera I must warn you, SLR's have a finite life, the shutter mechanism will eventually die out, so by using her camera for animation (which involves taking tons of pictures, if you hadn't noticed), you are speeding up her camera's journey to inevitable death; something to keep in mind.

I did some researching, and the shutter life of my sister's camera can go anywhere from 100,000 shots to 300,000 shots, like the average DSLR. I am pretty much the only one that uses the camera, despite the occasional 50 family photos about every four months or so. If I take about 8,000 photos a year, then that gives the camera a life of 12 1/2 years. When I go to college, the camera will still be a "youthful" camera, so I am not worried about its age, though thank you for the insight. I will stick with the DSLR and get a tripod, instead.

http://i1302.photobucket.com/albums/ag121/CavemanIncorporated/BiM_Sig_Monkey_zpse6d51622.jpg

Re: Webcam VS. DSLR

I'm confused, webcams such as the c920 allow use of zoom features I've used it and works fine, or am I missing something? mini/blankexpression

Moderator Notice: This user has been banned for mass vandalism of the Brikifilms wiki.]
"You don't know what you have till you lose it, but then when you realize it, it's probably to late.."
Working on a better community
Proverbs 26:21

Re: Webcam VS. DSLR

Generalned wrote:

I'm confused, webcams such as the c920 allow use of zoom features I've used it and works fine, or am I missing something? mini/blankexpression

The zoom on the c920 is digital, not optical, which isn't ideal as far as preserving detail; a traditional zoom lens would actually zoom in via the lens itself, whereas a digital zoom just blows the image up. That said, the C920 is a 15 megapixel camera, so you can probably afford to lose some resolution.

http://i.imgur.com/wcmcdmf.png

Re: Webcam VS. DSLR

Oh ok, thats understandable, nice hearing from you again.

Last edited by Generalned (January 8, 2013 (01:15pm))

Moderator Notice: This user has been banned for mass vandalism of the Brikifilms wiki.]
"You don't know what you have till you lose it, but then when you realize it, it's probably to late.."
Working on a better community
Proverbs 26:21

Re: Webcam VS. DSLR

Sméagol wrote:

That said, the C920 is a 15 megapixel camera, so you can probably afford to lose some resolution.

Mostly wrong. The optical sensor is actually only 3mp, even though they advertise it as 15mp (that's software-enhanced). Also, when I use the digital zoom, I can only zoom a little bit before the quality gets poor.

http://bricksafe.com/files/Legoguy501/BiM%20Signature.png
2nd place Darkness and Light entry: The Tree
Behind the Scenes