Topic: Anyone tried or build Motion Control with Mindstorms?

I'm just wondering if someone here tried or buld a motion control camera rig with Mindstorms?

I wish I could do it myself. But I'm affraid my dslr is too heavy for that.

Re: Anyone tried or build Motion Control with Mindstorms?

I don't know...but that would be a great way of doing specific computer controlled panning and dollying.

http://www.usa.canon.com/assets/app/images/callouts/cameras/callout_hdvideo_091511.jpg    http://www.usa.canon.com/assets/app/images/callouts/cameras/cdlc_148_rt.jpg

Re: Anyone tried or build Motion Control with Mindstorms?

Nah,mindstorms are expensive,but i might get some on the future.
mini/troll
CDP

Re: Anyone tried or build Motion Control with Mindstorms?

Good idea! mini/bigsmile
That would be a very easy way to make smoothe camera motion. mini/smile

YouTube channel
N00bToob ebovv

Re: Anyone tried or build Motion Control with Mindstorms?

I've tried to make some basic camera rigs with technic and I found it very difficult to get accurate small increments with Lego gears. I'd imagine the same is true with Mindstorms.

It could just be that my Technic skills are lacking though.

Re: Anyone tried or build Motion Control with Mindstorms?

0ldScratch wrote:

I've tried to make some basic camera rigs with technic and I found it very difficult to get accurate small increments with Lego gears. I'd imagine the same is true with Mindstorms.

It could just be that my Technic skills are lacking though.


Hmmm.. I think it can be done well. Although don't blame me, I'm optimistic mini/bigsmile. I haven't touched Lego technics for years and have practically no more lego left.

Maybe I should try making some rig designs with LDD that I have on my mind, so one can try them to build and see if they will work.

Re: Anyone tried or build Motion Control with Mindstorms?

I built a wench to move in accurate small increments with LEGO, it took a while, but it's pretty cool. It can be done, just need to be very careful. I plan on using it for slow mo shots, moving figs slowly then masking.

I imagine you'd be able to build something of the same sort to move a camera powered by mind stormers.
But it would probably be better to just crank a knob on the machine rather than have something electric power it, I don't think it would be really necessary.

Re: Anyone tried or build Motion Control with Mindstorms?

But the whole point of motion control rigs is that you need to be able to repeat the exact same movements over and over, so you can film the camera moving through the background, then film foreground elements separately. Hand cranking isn't going to give you that level of control.

Re: Anyone tried or build Motion Control with Mindstorms?

I believe chosen1 from Brickfilms.com made a Mindstorms camera rig. He posted some pictures a few years ago, but I guess they're offline now.

http://www.majhost.com/gallery/StudioL30/Random-Pictures/youtube.jpghttp://www.majhost.com/gallery/StudioL30/Random-Pictures/sitelogo.jpg

Re: Anyone tried or build Motion Control with Mindstorms?

0ldScratch wrote:

But the whole point of motion control rigs is that you need to be able to repeat the exact same movements over and over, so you can film the camera moving through the background, then film foreground elements separately. Hand cranking isn't going to give you that level of control.

Hand cranking can. I've built my thing as so a 360 turn of the knob moves the thing at the exact same  movement every time. It works pretty smoothly. Just need to turn the handle thingy once every frame and it's perfect.

Re: Anyone tried or build Motion Control with Mindstorms?

Got any pictures?

Re: Anyone tried or build Motion Control with Mindstorms?

I made a topic for it.
Pictures of the contraption, and a video of it working there.

It actually is a little bit bumpy there, though, I've improved it even more since then, adding more gears, and fixed it so that the movements would be even more smooth. Back then I did a quarter turn every frame, now I do a full turn.

I'm sure after a few days, one could come up with an interesting camera rig which uses gears similarly.