But have I performed a terrible song that has violated the worlds earlobes? Does being 13 really excuse that? Sure, she didn't write it, and she's a tool - but I'm joining in with the attempt to stop her making more songs. Trust me, her vanishing under a sea of hate will do her good when she's completely forgotten in five years time.

And I would love to see a video bashing me. Judging by how everyone avoids my films like the plague, and forgets what an opinion is, I'm surprised no-one has done one yet.

Last edited by Max Butcher (April 2, 2011 (12:44pm))

But who is going to buy her album? Who is going to watch her tour? Why are we talking about this anyway?

I understand that this thread is stirring controversy but we posted our review. We really need experience in reviewing films and such because I (JP3) might be looking to go to a college that offers journaling/descriptive writing (for lack of better words) as a major. This would be a big step to getting there.

Last edited by Juggernaut Pictures (April 2, 2011 (12:53pm))

Solution: Post more in the reviews forum

/thread

How about this? If you take the time to write thoughtful and informative reviews, people in the community will take note of it. You will accumulate respect and position from the others who inhabit our forum. As such, you will be more likely to receive attention for the creative endeavors you embark on, whether they be brickfilms, a discussion topic, or whatever else they may be.

People ought to put work into attaining a desired position. It's the definition of entitlement to expect a title and then work to earn it.

You can dismiss my point as "hammering" or "trolling" or what have you, but it might suit you to take a little feedback. Think of it as a review of your reviewing club prospectus.

Thanks for the feedback. Once again, I apologize for my retorts yesterday, which were unnecessary and unprovoked. Anyway, in response to your reply, I have done and continue to write in-depth reviews on their topics. I'm sure a lot of people can vouch for me here as well. If nothing else this is fun little club where people can share and critique each other's reviews, making for an overall improvement in the quality of feedback.

And I did also take Smeagol's advise - this is mainly a catalog of reviews posted on the threads in the releases section. For instance see Max Butcher's review, which was posted both here and in the selected thread. Now then, you may then ask why this thread is even needed, and the answer to that is that people can get feedback on their reviews, i.e 'Great review, although it seemed a little long... it was fine up until the point where you started talking about the ______ and _______. But good job anyway.'! This in time will hopefully mean we get a better official review panel on the site, which as far as I'm concerned is always a good thing.

So these are the purposes of this thread, just quickly:
1. A place where users can come to read reviews, as apposed to having to search out films in the releases section.
2. A place to catalog high quality reviews posted in the releases section.
3. A place to get feedback on your reviews.
4. An incentive to write reviews of films more often.

I hope that clears things up a bit. I appreciate the feedback and will happily take anymore given if possible. I apologize once again for my rash replies yesterday, I mis-worded some things also, which probably didn't help. Thanks for reading.

Right

Indeed, I have no talent for writing reviews and my english is very average.

Nevertheless, I'll try to make a review for the Onion's review panel. Thank you.

/ Youtube / Cinematography Challenge

I think it's good. I'm glad it wasn't too long, but I think you could have written a little bit more about the story.

I reviewed http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qQBFfeu6GFk/ film.
   

    My Review:
           
              The concept was good yet confusing at some points. I loved the part where the two characters were sucked into each other but the animation was kind of choppy with a little bit of light flicker. Like I said the concept was great but had a few flaws. First off, the idea was not original. It reminded me of Coraline and some other films. Secondly once he was in the second dimension nothing really happened except him getting combined with himself. A great idea yet poor execution but an overall score of 3 out of 5 because you captured my attention and kept me guessing. Well done

Last edited by buikes (May 12, 2011 (05:31pm))