Re: The OSCARS Thread - 2011

A fairly predictable list, but I'm happy to see John Hawkes and Jacki Weaver up in the Supporting categories, both were marvelous in their respective films. Also glad to see Exit Through the Gift Shop nominated in Documentary Feature, but surprised to see Waiting for Superman left out.

The biggest shocker by far, though, is Inception being left out for Best Director and Editing, both of which they greatly deserved (more so than its Original Screenplay nod, which I thought was one of the weaker aspects of the film). Unfortunately, I'm pretty sure those two snubs kill whatever chance Inception had at Best Picture (not that it had any chance, but it's no longer a leading candidate). Another small shocker is the absence of Andrew Garfield for Supporting Actor (The Social Network). I thought he was almost a shoo-in to make the cut, but I suppose not (John Hawkes is a good replacement, though, so I'm not too disappointed).

I fully expect The Social Network to take this handily, despite The King's Speech winning the Producer's Guild. TKS was a good film with fine performances, but hardly the best of the year. Plus, other than that one precursor, The Social Network has pretty much cleaned up everywhere else.

Also, I think True Grit may have gotten a little too much love from the Academy. I mean, it was a fine film, but I don't think it was worth 10 nominations.

Re: The OSCARS Thread - 2011

Well that stinks.
No love for Scott Pilgrim? Especially on ranks for music and sound? Bleh.
Toy Story 3 should win the best animated film, just beats the others by a mile.
Meh daft punk anyone? :s
Eh its only the oscars. :s

-Tejas VIM

Re: The OSCARS Thread - 2011

Sméagol wrote:

I think it's weird that Hailee Steinfeld was nominated as a supporting role and Jeff Bridges was nominated as a lead role; I have read a few arguments for these placements but I still feel like they're pretty blatantly inaccurate.  Jeff Bridges as a lead role is borderline though it makes enough sense, I guess, but the whole narrative is centered around the girl.

Agreed. I understand the why (more chance of winning supporting), but in terms of the narrative, Hailee is the lead. But I guess one could argue that's she's more of an antagonist, though.

EddieHasscle wrote:

Meh. There weren't that many good films this year. Ture Grit, Toy Story 3 and what else?

Did you watch any of the films nominated for best picture? It's a pretty solid list. Not to mention Exit Through the Gift Shop, etc. etc.

Shale wrote:

BOO! No Daft Punk nom for score.

- Shale, who hopes Exit Through the Gift Shop wins Best Documentary and that Banksy turns up to give an acceptance speech

Agreed, and definitely agreed.

And where was TRON: Legacy for visual effects?? Sure the young Jeff Bridges part at the beginning was awful, but the rest was amazing.

I would have also liked to see Scott Pilgrim for visual effects as well, but I don't think they did much campaigning.

VIMStudios wrote:

Well that stinks.
No love for Scott Pilgrim? Especially on ranks for music and sound?

I disagree on music, but think it should have been nominated for editing, adapted screenplay, sound editing/mixing, and visual effects. Maybe even director, but that's asking a lot. mini/smile

Re: The OSCARS Thread - 2011

WHERE THE HECK IS DAFT PUNK?!?!?!?

No, just NO. The Tourist had negative reviews yet it had a NOMINATION. And COME ON! Inception not winning ANYTHING? And, oh, what do I hear? The Social Network? Best Picture? Screenplay? I can't catch up on what you're saying. The Social Network is hypnotizing the judges! AAAAAAAH!!! mini/eek The Oscars are screwed. Good thing they didn't nominate Eclipse.

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

*facepalm*

Cinexcellence wrote:

And where was TRON: Legacy for visual effects?? Sure the young Jeff Bridges part at the beginning was awful, but the rest was amazing

THAT. IS. IT.

Last edited by Thunderbolt (January 26, 2011 (07:48am))

Back In Black!

Re: The OSCARS Thread - 2011

Thunderbolt wrote:

No, just NO. The Tourist had negative reviews yet it had a NOMINATION. And COME ON! Inception not winning ANYTHING

Are you talking about the Oscars or the Golden Globes?

The Tourist wasn't nominated for an Oscar, and the awards haven't been given out yet. Chill out.

Re: The OSCARS Thread - 2011

VIMStudios wrote:

Toy Story 3 should win the best animated film, just beats the others by a mile.
-Tejas VIM

Amen to that brother. mini/yes

Re: The OSCARS Thread - 2011

Lucas wrote:

I'm so excited about this! Harry Potter better win for SOMETHING!

Harry Potter wasn't even nominated, so it isn't happening.

Best picture is The Social Network without a doubt, but I'm torn between Jesse Eisenberg and James Franco for best actor. Even though Jesse Eisenberg is one of my favorite actors, I think Franco did a perfect job in 127 Hours.

My old YouTube is since long ago defunct - now even removed.
Here is my new one.

Re: The OSCARS Thread - 2011

Filip wrote:
Lucas wrote:

I'm so excited about this! Harry Potter better win for SOMETHING!

Harry Potter wasn't even nominated, so it isn't happening.

Best picture is The Social Network without a doubt, but I'm torn between Jesse Eisenberg and James Franco for best actor. Even though Jesse Eisenberg is one of my favorite actors, I think Franco did a perfect job in 127 Hours.

Did you even the full list if you think THAT'S the full list you are completely lost? it's nominated for Best Visual Effects and Art Direction...

Re: The OSCARS Thread - 2011

I'm utterly surprised by the lack of support towards the King's Speech. Unless of course the majority of you haven't seen it, in which case do. I just found it to be a very powerful and emotional film, and then of course it had some incredible shots, and the editing work wasn't half bad, considering their editor has just really taken on movies recently. And despite the praise for the Social Networks technical aspects, I think that TKS just had such a moving story in real life, and was portrayed in a way where that story was translated into film, thus creating an effect where the viewers feels for the characters involved.

Also - Jeff Bridges was nominated, and won, at last year's oscars. And now he's nominated again? I guess this must be the high-point in his career. Somehow though I feel there's too many other good actors around him for it to slip into his grasp as easily as it did before. And I conquer with MindGame on the subject of True Grit anyway.

I've also found it quite surprising at Inception's 7 nominations. Somehow I thought that it would be shunned away by the newer films out, but it's good to see it still has recognition. I'm also shocked at Black Swan's 5 nominations. While it's nothing to be sniffed at, I thought with the acclaim it's received it would be a real hard hitter like The King's Speech and The Social Network.

Toy Story 3 is a shoo-in for best animated picture, which I find myself quite annoyed at. Even though it might be the best of 3 mentioned (I personally enjoyed How To Train Your Dragon more), I just feel it doesn't deserve it. I mean, it was a great film, but it didn't need to be made, the story was left in a nice spot, and then they kind of went and wrecked it. Plus despite Pixar's always good work, I'm sick of seeing them win everything, especially when they beat the Secret of Kells with Up, which while lovely, didn't deserve it either. Hoping when Cartoon Saloon release their new animated film this coming year it gets in for 2012's oscars.

'look like it was shot at 2 FPS by a blindfolded five year old boy with broken fingers and no thumbs.' -PushOver
I'll be back animating soon! Exams and computer faults are keeping me away </3

Drifter (THAC 11) - Here

Re: The OSCARS Thread - 2011

LegOpinions wrote:

Toy Story 3 is a shoo-in for best animated picture, which I find myself quite annoyed at. Even though it might be the best of 3 mentioned (I personally enjoyed How To Train Your Dragon more), I just feel it doesn't deserve it. I mean, it was a great film, but it didn't need to be made, the story was left in a nice spot, and then they kind of went and wrecked it. Plus despite Pixar's always good work, I'm sick of seeing them win everything, especially when they beat the Secret of Kells with Up, which while lovely, didn't deserve it either. Hoping when Cartoon Saloon release their new animated film this coming year it gets in for 2012's oscars.

Dude Toy Story 3 is one of the finest masterpieces ever. It did have to be made. Pixar had a story to tell the audience and they pulled that off fantasticly cause people always wanted to see what would happen when Andy grew up and on that note YES IT HAD TO BE MADE. Pixar makes amazing films (except Cars) and that's why they always win. They did it better. The put time on one movie while Dreamworks releases 3 movies and 2 of them was not really that good.

Re: The OSCARS Thread - 2011

Look - Toy Story 3 a masterpiece? That's a strict matter of opinion. It was visually good, but the story lacked and they relied on one big piece of the story to resort back to the second film, where a toy was morealess abandoned by his/her owner - it's just it didn't ruin Jessie. Pixar, admittedly, are incredible - no denying - but it doesn't mean they have the top film every year.

'look like it was shot at 2 FPS by a blindfolded five year old boy with broken fingers and no thumbs.' -PushOver
I'll be back animating soon! Exams and computer faults are keeping me away </3

Drifter (THAC 11) - Here

Re: The OSCARS Thread - 2011

LegOpinions wrote:

Pixar, admittedly, are incredible - no denying - but it doesn't mean they have the top film every year.

Yes they do. YES THEY DAMN WELL DO!!!

http://i.imgur.com/WAr6hHC.png
BRAWL 2013 ENTRY Quack In Time
"Why in the world did you do a weird language if you know English?" - tenny1028

Re: The OSCARS Thread - 2011

That was probably a joke, but let's stick to constructive conversation.

The Rules wrote:

Insults, threats, and abusive comments:  Criticizing someone else's work is acceptable, but rude name-calling and threats are not.  You may only mean to be sarcastic or joking, but if this isn't going to be clear to people, please think before posting.  Any comments of an abusive nature (racist, sexist, or homophobic slurs) are not allowed. Trolling and starting off-topic arguments based around insults is not permissible.

Re: The OSCARS Thread - 2011

LegOpinions wrote:

I'm utterly surprised by the lack of support towards the King's Speech. Unless of course the majority of you haven't seen it, in which case do. I just found it to be a very powerful and emotional film, and then of course it had some incredible shots, and the editing work wasn't half bad, considering their editor has just really taken on movies recently. And despite the praise for the Social Networks technical aspects, I think that TKS just had such a moving story in real life, and was portrayed in a way where that story was translated into film, thus creating an effect where the viewers feels for the characters involved.

See, I thought almost the exact opposite. The King's Speech, to me at least, seems like pretty generic Oscar-bait: it's a crowd-pleasing, British period film with strong lead performances by well-respected actors. It seems like the kind of film that would do well come nomination time, but otherwise, I didn't see anything particularly groundbreaking with it. The story is told decently well, and Firth and Rush do great jobs with their roles (though Helena Bonham Carter is grossly underutilized, and I don't think she deserves her nomination), but I didn't walk away from the theater thinking I it was the best film of the year.

Last edited by MindGame (January 26, 2011 (01:38pm))

Re: The OSCARS Thread - 2011

Toy Story 3 and The Kings Speech were stand-outs for me, but both for incredibly Biased reasons. Personally, I thought 'The Kings Speech' was an incredibly well-made movie with the cinematography, sound design, acting, and script working in perfect harmony. Its not the best film I've seen, but definitely one of the best I had seen last year (although I have not seen some of the other nominations) in my opinion. I agree that Helena Bonham Carter was merely nominated because she's Helena Bonham Carter - and whilst she played her role well didn't have enough screen-time to deserve a nomination. So why do I like it so much when its pretty similar to other Oscar-Bait films?

Because its English.

Those who read the 'Worst Movies' thread will know that I am getting tired of Pixar being given orgasmic status along with Christopher Nolan and *groan* 'Avatar' (although people I know are gradually beginning to realise what it underneath the pretty visuals: nothing). Sure, their movies are above the standard of other animations out there (*COUGH*Dreamworks*COUGH*), but both Up and Wall.e seemed to me like they were trying too hard to be emotionally involved and instead were incredibly over-dramatic and unappealing to watch - following the logic that its OK to directly confront the issue of death as long as there is a 'happy' ending taped on. Its just uncomfortable, and distances me from the movie. I know movies that are meant to make you feel uncomfortable and distance you, but they are using it to create a critical audience. Pixar is NOT critical!! Wall.e was trying to create a message about the environment which I have seen....uh.....ONE MILLION TIMES BEFORE!!!

Anyways, late-night rant aside, I like Toy Story 3. Sure, it was over dramatic at times, but not as much as in Up and Wall.e. My liking for it is that I've grown up with it, therefore am completely biased towards it. Script, cinematography, and story-wise, it was pretty good - but not excellent or outstanding. I didn't really notice the improved textures and stuff, and anyone who uses this as an argument for why it is the greatest movie of 2010 needs to stock up on classic cinema (and watch 'Memento')

Thunderbolt wrote:

The Tourist had negative reviews yet it had a NOMINATION.

'The Tourist' received a Golden Globe Nomination for Best Supporting Actress (I think). According to the negative reviews, everything else sucks. Its like 'Robin Hood: Prince of Thieves' received a nomination for Best Original Song, but received a Razzie Nomination for 'Worst Movie' (I know this because said movie is my favourite of all time - even though it fully deserves the latter nomination)

YouTube
Max, She/Her

Re: The OSCARS Thread - 2011

Max Butcher wrote:

'The Tourist' received a Golden Globe Nomination for Best Supporting Actress (I think).

Actually, it got nominations in Best Motion Picture - Comedy or Musical, Best Actor - Comedy or Musical, and Best Actress - Comedy or Musical. The fact that it got these nominations at all is certainly inexplicable, but even stranger is the classification of the film as a comedy or musical. Oh well, it's not like anyone respected the Golden Globes much anyway.

I think some of the Oscar nominations The King's Speech got should have gone to other films. Inception clearly deserved editing more, and I would have rather seen Mila Kunis nominated for Supporting Actress than Helena Bonham Carter. Of course I'm also saddened by Christopher Nolan missing out on directing.

Re: The OSCARS Thread - 2011

I'm so happy that Toy Story 3 got nominated because I honestly think it was the best animated film. mini/smile

http://i.imgur.com/CSwoca1.png

Re: The OSCARS Thread - 2011

I'm somewhat surprised that the David Guggenheim's Waiting for "Superman" wasn't nominated for best documentary.

Re: The OSCARS Thread - 2011

Cinexcellence wrote:
VIMStudios wrote:

Well that stinks.
No love for Scott Pilgrim? Especially on ranks for music and sound?

I disagree on music, but think it should have been nominated for editing, adapted screenplay, sound editing/mixing, and visual effects. Maybe even director, but that's asking a lot. mini/smile

I rewatched Scott Pilgrim yesterday and I totally forgot about the editing. And after watching it a second time the score didnt strike to me as it did in the first watch. As for best director, ehh, kinda a long shot.
But still, phooey on Oscars for missing that and Nolan for best directed.

-Tejas VIM

Re: The OSCARS Thread - 2011

LegOpinions wrote:

BEST SUPPORTING ACTRESS]
Amy Adams, The Fighter
Helena Bonham Carter, The King’s Speech
Melissa Leo, The Fighter
Hailee Steinfeld, True Grit]
Jacki Weaver, Animal Kingdom

What? She was the main character.

Also, while I'm here, I might as well add that Helena Bonham Carter did a great job in The King's Speech.